Square Online vs Sellfy Website Builder Comparison

Written by

Our content is reader-supported. If you click on our links, we may earn a commission. How we review.

In this straightforward analysis, we delve into the world of e-commerce, specifically focusing on Square Online vs Sellfy. As an experienced website building specialist, I’ve sifted through the noise to give you the nitty-gritty details of these services, helping you make an informed choice for your online business.

Overview

Square Online and Sellfy are both website builders that cater to different needs. Square Online is a robust platform that offers a variety of features for creating professional e-commerce websites. It provides a user-friendly interface, customizable templates, and seamless integration with Square’s payment processing system. On the other hand, Sellfy is a platform specifically designed for selling digital products. It offers easy product management, secure file hosting, and various marketing tools. Depending on your specific requirements, both Square Online and Sellfy can be great options for building your online store.

Square Online

Square Online

Free Plan: Yes

Free Trial: No (but has refund policy)

Price: From $36 per month

Official website: www.squareup.com

Square Online Online is best suited for small to medium-sized businesses seeking to establish an online presence or sell products and services online.

Learn more about Square Online

Sellfy

Sellfy

Free Plan: No

Free Trial: No (but has refund policy)

Price: From $19 per month

Official website: www.sellfy.com

Sellfy is best suited for creators, online marketers, and small businesses looking to sell digital products, physical goods, or subscriptions online.

Learn more about Sellfy

Square Online has revolutionized my business operations! Their intuitive interface, seamless payment processing, and robust features have significantly improved efficiency. Exceptional customer service too. Highly recommend for businesses seeking a reliable online platform. – Mark X

starstarstarstarstar

Sellfy has transformed my e-commerce business. The platform is user-friendly, with seamless digital product delivery. Their support team is highly responsive, and the analytics are insightful. It’s a game-changer for online sellers. Highly recommend! – Richard J

starstarstarstarstar

Efficient platform, user-friendly interface. Square Online simplifies transactions. Few minor issues, but customer service was responsive. Highly recommended. – Jackson

starstarstarstar

Efficient platform, user-friendly interface. Fast transactions, reasonable fees. Minor glitches, but Sellfy’s customer service is commendable. Overall, highly recommend. – Benjamin

starstarstarstar

Square Online simplifies e-commerce. Its intuitive, user-friendly interface and robust features streamline business operations. Exceptional customer service tops off a stellar platform. Highly recommended for all businesses. – Samuel

starstarstarstarstar

Sellfy provides seamless e-commerce solutions. Exceptionally user-friendly interface, robust features, and stellar customer service. Highly recommend for anyone seeking to elevate their online selling experience. – Lily

starstarstarstarstar

Pros & Cons

This section explores the strengths and weaknesses of these two website builders.

Winner is:

Square Online and Sellfy are two popular platforms for creating online stores. Square Online offers a user-friendly interface, robust features like inventory management, and integration with Square’s payment processing. However, it lacks advanced customization options and has limited design templates. On the other hand, Sellfy excels in simplicity, with a focus on digital products. It offers customizable themes, powerful marketing tools, and seamless integration with popular payment gateways. Overall, Square Online is the winner for its comprehensive features and wider range of e-commerce capabilities.

Square Online

Square Online

Pros:
  • Free plan: Square Online offers a free plan that includes all the basic features you need to create a website, including a domain name, hosting, and SSL certificate.
  • Easy to use: Square Online uses a drag-and-drop interface that makes it easy to create a website even if you don’t have any coding experience.
  • Built-in eCommerce features: Square Online includes all the features you need to sell products online, including product inventory management, shipping and tax calculation, and payment processing.
  • Free SSL certificate: Your Square Online website will come with a free SSL certificate, which ensures that your website is secure for customers to use.
  • SEO tools: Square Online includes built-in SEO tools to help you improve your website’s ranking in search results.
  • Integration with Square POS: Square Online integrates with Square POS, so you can easily manage your inventory and sales across all channels.
  • Accept multiple payment methods: Square Online accepts all major credit cards, as well as PayPal, Apple Pay, and Google Pay.
  • 24/7 customer support: Square offers 24/7 customer support to help you with any issues you may have with your Square Online website.
Cons:
  • Limited design flexibility: Square Online’s templates are limited in terms of design flexibility. You can’t make major changes to the layout or colors of your website.
  • No advanced features: Square Online doesn’t offer some advanced features that are available on other website builders, such as abandoned cart recovery and CRM tools.
  • Transaction fees: Square Online charges transaction fees for all sales, even on the free plan.
  • No custom domain name on free plan: You can’t use a custom domain name with your Square Online website on the free plan. You’ll need to upgrade to a paid plan to use a custom domain name.
Sellfy

Sellfy

Pros:
  • Easy to use: Sellfy is a very user-friendly platform that is perfect for beginners. You can create your store and start selling products in minutes, without any coding knowledge.
  • Sell digital and physical products: Sellfy allows you to sell both digital and physical products. This makes it a great platform for creators who want to sell their digital products, such as ebooks, music, and software, as well as for businesses that want to sell physical products, such as clothing, accessories, and home goods.
  • Built-in marketing tools: Sellfy comes with a number of built-in marketing tools that can help you promote your store and sell more products. These tools include discount codes, email marketing, and social media integration.
  • Analytics: Sellfy provides you with detailed analytics about your store, so you can track your sales, traffic, and customers. This information can help you make informed decisions about your marketing and product strategy.
  • Secure payment processing: Sellfy uses a secure payment processor to protect your customers’ financial information. This ensures that your customers can shop with confidence on your store.
  • Free trial: Sellfy offers a free trial so you can try out the platform before you commit to a paid plan. This is a great way to see if Sellfy is a good fit for your business.
Cons:
  • Limited customization options: Sellfy’s templates are very limited in terms of customization. You can only change the colors and fonts, and you can’t add any custom code. This can be a problem for businesses that want to create a unique and branded store.
  • Limited integrations: Sellfy only integrates with a limited number of apps and plugins. This can be a problem for businesses that use a lot of third-party software.
  • High transaction fees: Sellfy charges a high transaction fee of 5% for all sales. This can be a significant cost for businesses that sell high-priced products.
  • No customer support phone number: Sellfy only offers email and live chat support. This can be a problem for businesses that need to get help quickly.

Website Building Features

This section compares the overall features of Square Online vs Sellfy.

Winner is:

When comparing Square Online and Sellfy, both website builders offer a drag and drop interface, allowing users to easily build and customize their online stores. Square Online offers a wider range of professional and modern templates and designs, giving users more options to create a visually appealing store. While Sellfy focuses solely on e-commerce, Square Online provides additional features like booking appointments and managing inventory. In terms of value for money, Square Online offers more robust features and flexibility at a competitive price. Both platforms offer basic SEO and email marketing capabilities, but Square Online‘s integration with Square’s suite of tools gives it an edge. Square Online also provides enhanced security features and reliable customer support. Therefore, the overall winner is Square Online.

Square Online

Square Online

  • Free website hosting and domain for one year: You can create a free website with Square Online and get a free domain for the first year.
  • Easy-to-use website builder: Square Online uses a drag-and-drop interface that makes it easy to create a website even if you don’t have any coding experience.
  • Built-in eCommerce features: Square Online includes all the features you need to sell products online, including product inventory management, shipping and tax calculation, and payment processing.
  • Free SSL certificate: Your Square Online website will come with a free SSL certificate, which ensures that your website is secure for customers to use.
  • SEO tools: Square Online includes built-in SEO tools to help you improve your website’s ranking in search results.
  • Integration with Square POS: Square Online integrates with Square POS, so you can easily manage your inventory and sales across all channels.
  • Accept multiple payment methods: Square Online accepts all major credit cards, as well as PayPal, Apple Pay, and Google Pay.
  • 24/7 customer support: Square offers 24/7 customer support to help you with any issues you may have with your Square Online website.
Sellfy

Sellfy

  • Easy to use: Sellfy is a very user-friendly platform that is perfect for beginners. You can create your store and start selling products in minutes, without any coding knowledge.
  • Sell digital and physical products: Sellfy allows you to sell both digital and physical products. This makes it a great platform for creators who want to sell their digital products, such as ebooks, music, and software, as well as for businesses that want to sell physical products, such as clothing, accessories, and home goods.
  • Built-in marketing tools: Sellfy comes with a number of built-in marketing tools that can help you promote your store and sell more products. These tools include discount codes, email marketing, and social media integration.
    • Subscriptions: You can sell subscriptions to your products or services. This is a great way to generate recurring revenue.
  • Analytics: Sellfy provides you with detailed analytics about your store, so you can track your sales, traffic, and customers. This information can help you make informed decisions about your marketing and product strategy.
  • Secure payment processing: Sellfy uses a secure payment processor to protect your customers’ financial information. This ensures that your customers can shop with confidence on your store.
  • Free trial: Sellfy offers a free trial so you can try out the platform before you commit to a paid plan. This is a great way to see if Sellfy is a good fit for your business.
  • Embedding: You can embed your Sellfy store on your own website or blog. This is a great way to sell your products to an existing audience.
  • Print-on-demand: Sellfy offers print-on-demand services, so you can sell products with your designs on them without having to worry about inventory or shipping.
  • Multilingual support: Sellfy supports over 20 languages, so you can sell your products to customers all over the world.

Ease of Use

This section focuses on ease of use and how beginner-friendly Square Online and Sellfy are.

Winner is:

When it comes to the drag-and-drop interface and ease of use, Square Online and Sellfy both excel. Square Online offers a user-friendly interface with intuitive design elements, making it easy for beginners to create a professional website. Sellfy also provides a simple drag-and-drop builder with a seamless user experience. However, in terms of overall ease of use, Square Online takes the lead due to its more extensive customization options and robust features. Thus, Square Online emerges as the winner in this comparison.

Square Online

Square Online

  • Intuitive interface: Square Online’s user-friendly design enables quick learning and effortless navigation.
  • Drag-and-drop feature: This tool simplifies website creation, no coding required.
  • Customizable: Offers myriad design options to personalize your site, matching brand style seamlessly.
  • Seamless product addition: Easy-to-use tools for adding and organizing products.
  • Integrated payment system: Quick setup for secure transactions.
  • Mobile-friendly: Automatically optimizes your site for mobile devices.
  • Comprehensive dashboard: Manage and monitor your business with ease.
  • SEO tools: Simple, embedded tools to boost your online presence.
  • 24/7 customer support: Always available to answer any queries.
  • Free trial: Risk-free opportunity to test its user-friendliness.
Sellfy

Sellfy

  • Intuitive interface: Sellfy’s user-friendly dashboard makes navigation a breeze.
  • Drag-and-drop feature: Easily organize your digital storefront with a simple ‘drag and drop’ system.
  • Customization: Personalize your shop with brand colors, logos, and layout adjustments.
  • Straightforward product uploading: Add products swiftly with clear prompts and fields.
  • Streamlined checkout: Sellfy provides a seamless, quick checkout process for customers.
  • Integrated marketing tools: Easily set up promotional campaigns from the dashboard.
  • Analytic insights: Understanding your sales and audience is effortless with Sellfy’s inbuilt analytics.
  • Mobile optimization: The platform is fully responsive, ensuring a smooth experience on any device.
  • Quick setup: Get your online store running in minutes with Sellfy’s efficient setup process.

Templates & Designs

This section looks at the themes of Sellfy and Square Online in terms of in terms of customization, the number of templates, and templates for websites, and e-commerce sites.

Winner is:

When it comes to templates and designs, Square Online and Sellfy both offer a range of options for customization. Square Online provides a wide selection of modern and professional templates for both websites and e-commerce sites, allowing businesses to create a unique online presence. On the other hand, Sellfy focuses primarily on e-commerce, offering a smaller but still visually appealing selection of templates. In terms of customization, Square Online takes the lead with its drag-and-drop editor and flexible design options. Therefore, Square Online is the overall winner when it comes to templates and designs.

Square Online

Square Online

  • Offers range of customizable templates.
  • Designs cater to various sectors like retail, food, services.
  • Mobile-optimized templates for on-the-go shopping.
  • Drag-and-drop website builder for easy design.
  • Templates support eCommerce features.
  • Integrated with Square POS system.
  • Options for SEO-friendly, clean, and modern designs.
  • Includes free and premium templates.
Types of Templates:
  • Ecommerce:
    • Online Ordering Page: This template is a simple way to sell products online without the need for a full website.
    • Multi-Page eCommerce: This template allows you to create a full website with multiple pages, including a product catalog, a blog, and a contact page.
  • Personal:
    • Artist: This template is perfect for artists and creative professionals who want to showcase their work online.
    • Photographer: This template is perfect for photographers who want to share their photos with the world.
    • Personal: This template is a great option for anyone who wants to create a simple, personal website.
  • Business:
    • Restaurant: This template is perfect for restaurants who want to take their business online.
    • Salon: This template is perfect for salons and spas who want to reach a wider audience.
    • Retail: This template is perfect for retailers who want to sell their products online.
Sellfy

Sellfy

  • Sellfy provides customizable storefront templates for online businesses.
  • Offers a variety of product display layouts.
  • Provides pre-designed social media marketing templates.
  • Includes eBook and digital product design templates.
  • Has eye-catching banner and header designs.
  • Offers customizable checkout and shopping cart templates.
  • Provides templates for email marketing.
  • Offers user-friendly mobile-responsive designs.
Types of Templates:
  • Music Maker: This template is perfect for music creators who want to sell their beats, samples, and other music products. It has a clean and modern design that is easy to use and customize.
  • Inspiration: This template is perfect for creative professionals who want to sell their digital products, such as ebooks, templates, and fonts. It has a stylish and elegant design that will help you showcase your work.
  • Technify: This template is perfect for tech startups and businesses that want to sell their digital products, such as software, apps, and plugins. It has a modern and minimalist design that will help you make a great first impression on your customers.
  • Blackpress: This template is perfect for bloggers and journalists who want to sell their digital products, such as ebooks, courses, and memberships. It has a clean and professional design that is perfect for showcasing your content.
  • Simplon: This template is perfect for food bloggers and chefs who want to sell their digital products, such as recipes, cookbooks, and meal plans. It has a colorful and inviting design that will make your food look delicious.
  • Magnic: This template is perfect for magazine publishers and content creators who want to sell their digital products, such as articles, videos, and podcasts. It has a modern and stylish design that will help you engage your audience.
  • Sentify: This template is perfect for agencies and creative professionals who want to sell their services. It has a clean and professional design that will help you showcase your work and attract new clients.

Apps & Integrations

This section explores what apps, plugins, and integrations Square Online and Sellfy come with.

Winner is:

Both Square Online and Sellfy offer a range of apps, plugins, and integrations to enhance the functionality of your online store. Square Online provides seamless integrations with popular tools like Instagram, Facebook, and Google, allowing you to easily promote and sell your products. Sellfy, on the other hand, offers integrations with platforms like YouTube and Vimeo, making it easy to sell digital products. While both platforms offer useful integrations, Square Online takes the lead with its wider range of options and compatibility with multiple platforms. Therefore, Square Online emerges as the overall winner in terms of apps, plugins, and integrations.

Square Online

Square Online

  • Marketing:
    • Mailchimp: This app allows you to integrate your Square Online website with Mailchimp, so you can easily send email newsletters to your customers.
    • Facebook Pixel: This app allows you to track the activity of your website visitors on Facebook, so you can target them with ads.
    • Google Analytics: This app allows you to track the traffic to your website and see how visitors are interacting with your content.
  • Sales:
    • WooCommerce: This plugin allows you to sell products on your Square Online website using the popular WooCommerce platform.
    • Amazon Pay: This plugin allows you to accept payments from Amazon customers on your Square Online website.
    • PayPal: This plugin allows you to accept payments from PayPal customers on your Square Online website.
  • Other:
    • LiveChat: This app allows you to add a live chat widget to your Square Online website, so you can chat with visitors in real time.
    • Yoast SEO: This plugin helps you optimize your Square Online website for search engines.
    • TrustPulse: This app displays social proof on your Square Online website, such as customer testimonials and product reviews.
Sellfy

Sellfy

  • Zapier: Zapier is an automation tool that can connect Sellfy with hundreds of other apps, such as Google Analytics, Mailchimp, and Slack. This can help you automate tasks, such as sending welcome emails to new customers or creating social media posts when you launch a new product.
  • Webhooks: Webhooks are a way to send data from Sellfy to other apps in real time. This can be used to create custom integrations, such as sending order notifications to your CRM or updating your inventory levels in your accounting software.
  • Google Analytics: Google Analytics is a powerful tool that can help you track your website traffic and sales. Sellfy integrates with Google Analytics so you can see how people are finding your store and what they are buying.
  • Facebook Pixel: Facebook Pixel is a code snippet that you can add to your website to track your Facebook ads. Sellfy integrates with Facebook Pixel so you can see how many people who clicked on your ads made a purchase on your store.
  • Mailchimp: Mailchimp is an email marketing platform that can help you stay in touch with your customers. Sellfy integrates with Mailchimp so you can easily send welcome emails, abandoned cart emails, and other promotional emails to your customers.
  • Stripe: Stripe is a payment processor that can help you accept credit cards and other forms of payment on your store. Sellfy integrates with Stripe so you can easily process payments and get paid for your products.
  • PayPal: PayPal is another popular payment processor that can be integrated with Sellfy. PayPal is a good option for businesses that want to accept payments from international customers.

Customer Support

This section explores the strengths and weaknesses of the customer support provided by Square Online versus Sellfy.

Winner is:

Both Square Online and Sellfy offer excellent customer support to their users. Square Online provides 24/7 phone and email support, ensuring that any issues or questions are promptly addressed. Sellfy also offers responsive customer support, with a dedicated support team available via email. However, Square Online takes the lead in this category with its round-the-clock availability and multiple channels for assistance. Overall, Square Online edges out Sellfy with its comprehensive customer support options, ensuring that users have the necessary help whenever they need it.

Square Online

Square Online

  • 24/7 phone support: Square offers 24/7 phone support for all customers, regardless of their plan.
  • Email support: Square also offers email support for all customers.
  • Live chat: Square offers live chat support for customers on the Business plan and above.
  • Knowledge base: Square has a comprehensive knowledge base that covers all aspects of using Square Online Website Builder.
  • Community forum: Square has a community forum where users can ask questions and get help from other users.
  • Tutorials: Square offers a number of tutorials that can help you learn how to use Square Online Website Builder.
Sellfy

Sellfy

  • Email support: Sellfy offers 24/7 email support for all customers. You can submit a ticket through the Sellfy website and a customer support representative will get back to you within 24 hours.
  • Live chat: Sellfy offers live chat support during business hours (Pacific Time). You can chat with a customer support representative directly from the Sellfy website to get help with your account or any other questions you may have.
  • Knowledge base: Sellfy has a comprehensive knowledge base that covers a wide range of topics, including how to use Sellfy, how to set up your store, and how to troubleshoot problems. You can find the knowledge base by clicking on the “Help” tab on the Sellfy website.
  • Tutorials: Sellfy offers a number of video tutorials that can help you learn how to use Sellfy. You can find the tutorials on the Sellfy website or on the Sellfy YouTube channel.
  • Community forum: Sellfy has a community forum where you can ask questions and get help from other Sellfy users. The community forum is a great resource for finding answers to your questions and getting help with specific problems.

Check out how Square Online and Sellfy stack up against other website builder tools on the market.